Sometimes a conversation is started, and I find myself wanting to join it, but often do so much later than everyone else and then my voice gets lost in the midst of the next conversation that is already starting. Well, here I go again, even with this realization. C'est la vie.
Earlier this week I read
this blog post by Kate Baer on the
Mennonite World Review's website. She explains her personal sentiments about why she, like many other millenials (a.k.a. those currently 20-30 years old), no longer go to church on a regular basis, if at all, even if they still believe in God or label themselves as Christians.
Having finally settled into the beginning of a "real" adult life with all of its lovely responsibilities, I can appreciate and resonate with some of her reasons. "Sleeping in" tops the list of these reasons for me. Having weird (and sometimes long) working hours practically seven days a week, getting a chance to catch up on sleep is a rare luxury for me, and Sundays seem as a good of a day as any. Living in D.C., there are a lot of millenials, and Sunday brunch and/or visiting the local farmers' market are very popular activities for Sunday mornings as well. Put extra sleep together with a visit to Eastern Market followed by a brunch of french toast, bacon, and mimosas, and I am pretty much in love. So I can find it very easy to resonate with wanting a day to take it easy and not worry about having to be somewhere yet again.
I also can understand how church can be boring. The same routine, Sunday after Sunday, is quite repetitive, especially in a congregation that doesn't like to switch up their order of service at all. Sermons aren't always exciting and I find myself zoning out many-a-Sunday during the sermon, even though they don't drag on too long in my congregation. Sometimes new hymns/songs are chosen and make you feel awkward because no one seems to know how or what to sing. Often announcement time takes forever, and while sharing of joys and concerns is important, sometimes you wonder why certain people get up and say the things they do during that time. Oh how cynical and judgmental I can be in church.
Which brings me to her next point: cynicism. The last decade or so has shown just how hypocritical and full of abuse the church really is. Messages of hate spew from pulpits all over the place and the truth is covered up to protect leaders in prominent positions. Things are pretty messed up (there are plenty of other verbs I could've chosen, but I'm trying to keep it clean). It's no wonder so many millenials (and others) no longer go to church; they are getting mixed messages almost everywhere they go. Identifying as "Christian" can be a scary thing when the rest of the world sees "Christians" in the media saying "God hates fags", "Hurricane Katrina is the wrath of God", "Islam is an abomination", and other negative messages.
As I said, I can understand, and certainly at times resonate, with Baer's feelings. But then I separate with her actions and sentiments, following a similar path my fellow Blufftonite
Hannah Heinzekehr wrote about on her own blog The Femonite.
She writes:
"But I am growing tired of continuing to read post after post about why young adults are leaving the church or why millennials find Sunday morning services worthless. I would much rather read from people about the places and communities they have found that work. About those experiences and moments that do point them towards the Divine. Mostly I just wish that we could stop expecting church to be free from the brokenness that is endemic to the human condition."
I don't say things like this often, but "Amen, sister!"
She continues on to discuss the problem of "Sunday best" and how it seems we need to be perfect or white-washed to go to church rather than be openly broken with our "shit showing".
Oh Hannah, you just had to bring up the term "Sunday best", didn't you? This is where I find myself at odds with so many people today. I don't disagree that we are a broken, imperfect people, and church should be the first place where we can bring all of our burdens to share. I wish there was so much more of this happening, where church is a place where people can be truly "real" about who they are, where they are, and what they are. I wish I could be more open than I am in church. I really wish I could believe more in the power of communal/intercessory prayer and present my troubles before the congregation openly without judgment. I wish others would/could do the same. I wish I didn't trivialize certain peoples worries and prayer requests. I wish I wasn't so afraid. I wish I could cuss openly in church. I wish there was much more discussion, and a little less preaching at.
But, at the same time, we are in church to worship God, praise Him/Her/Them for all that has been created and given to us. We should be in awe at all that remains inexplicable about our world and universe, knowing a Sovereign Creator/Creatrix is behind it all. Recognizing the power of I AM is a humbling experience that I have over and over again, and not just on Sundays, but it is on Sunday when I come to specifically recognize this. I believe in the idea of Sunday best; I come to church to present myself as a small piece of all creation, and I am presenting myself before the One who created it all. Why shouldn't I be all dressed up for church? For me, putting on some of my finest is a sign of respect for I AM, recognizing Thy power and glory and knowing there is nothing I could ever do to match it. At the same time,
Gott ist die Liebe, and while it can be quite scary to recognize how insignificant our lives can be in the grand scheme of things, we should also recognize that love should conquer all, and we shouldn't be afraid to lay ourselves bare (again, I'm hypocrite for saying this, but maybe someday I'll do better).
Also, I agree with Heinzekehr: if we're frustrated with what's happening in church, maybe we should try harder to change it, rather than simply give up on it. Sometimes this is a lot easier said than done, and sometimes change will never happen (in nature everything eventually dies, and some congregations ultimately need to face the same fate for something new to be born). But simply giving in means defeat, and we shouldn't let a hateful message win over our belief in God's peace and love. It's time we create better communities of love, support, peace, and justice within our churches rather than fall for the same routines again and again. I'm not necessarily advocating for the abolition of traditional worship (I'm a strong defender of traditional hymn singing and reading the Bible aloud), but I think are better ways to sometimes do church rather than always be a passive parishioner in the pew.
At this point in my life, I attend a congregation I have a strong love for, even though their is a hate side to this relationship (also, I work for my church, so that colors some of my opinions) (you can also read some earlier reflections on why I go to church
here,
here, and
here). My congregation, Hyattsville Mennonite Church (HMC), in Hyattsville, MD (a D.C. suburb), is a smaller (130 average attendance), urban Mennonite church that has been around for over 60 years. But almost since its inception, HMC has caused problems and headaches for those in church leadership. Longer ago, there were two main Mennonite denominations in North America. HMC was born out of one, but being the only congregation in D.C. during the 1950s and 60s, it was the only place where people of both denominations could worship in a comfortable, familiar setting. This angered some in the regional conference leadership, wanting to keep denominational separation. But HMC refused to follow this advice, and so there was in the beginning a sense of hospitality to all who wanted to worship there.
Nowadays, HMC is known for its long-held stance on welcoming LGBTQ, etc. people. This inclusion, which started back in the 1980s, led to discipline from the regional conference over seven years ago, which means HMC has no voting rights in the regional conference or the national denomination. While we are still part of the denomination, we have no official say on important matters. This has not stopped us from participating as much as we can; we still attend national convention, delegates continue to show up at ever regional conference meeting, money is constantly sent to various denominational agencies. Thankfully, a process of reconciliation is starting with the regional conference, although no one knows what this means yet.
I once overheard an older child say HMC is the best church to attend if you're an atheist. I don't think this is quite true, but it is encouraging to know children in our congregation recognize it's okay to question one's faith and openly wrestle with issues of theology, etc. They (the children) seem to understand God is love and such love is accepting of all, whether they are a man, woman, or otherwise; upper, middle, lower class, or otherwise; single, married, divorced, have kids, or otherwise; hetero, homo, bi, trans, queer, pan, inter, asexual, or otherwise; mentally, physically, emotionally, spiritually handicapped or otherwise.
There are a great many people who aren't afraid to talk to you, invite you to their homes, share their resources and wealth (or lack thereof) with you, no matter if they work for the government, a school, in retail, IT, stay at home, or otherwise. They are willing to chip in at the last minute to help those in need in the surrounding communities. I show up in some pretty fancy clothes, while many others wear T-shirts and jeans, and yet we are all (mostly) fine with that. Jokes about alcohol and skirting around swear words happen more often than you would think during worship services. No one is refused communion.
On 10 February, I tweeted this: "An Indonesian in a bluegrass band that plays at the legal wedding of two women during the worship service. I love my church . . ."
Yet, despite all of this diversity and openness, there seems to be a strong dislike of changing Sunday worship. Heaven forbid a projector screen be put up. I can't recall the last time we sang two hymns in a row; of course we never sing any contemporary songs, unless they are already printed somewhere with sheet music. When was the last time we just stood up to shake hands and greet those around us, in 2011? And what is up with needing to stick to the liturgical calendar for scripture readings each Sunday and following the traditional church seasons? Why must it all be about Advent and traditional Christmas is a bad thing? Can someone explain to me why "Alleluia" is such a horrible thing to say/sing during Lent? While I certainly like what I like with church, I sometimes think HMC could relax a bit more and say "it's alright to go with the flow" and "we can deal" with changes in the order of service from week to week (this probably is a product of growing up in a Mennonite congregation where we never followed the liturgical calendar and worship styles changed from week to week).
Obviously I can ramble on and on. While there are certainly some Sundays when I just want to not leave my bed until 11:00 a.m., most of the time, I honestly do enjoy going to church. It gives me another community to connect with and belong to. Most of the time there is great music and the congregation, while smaller, has a mighty singing voice. The pastor isn't afraid to be real (and sometimes swear) with you. Potlucks are plentiful. Judgment from others remains low (or at least unspoken). Most importantly, people are encouraged to come as they are, broken, imperfect parts of creation that are still called to love one another, bring peace to one another, and act justly towards one another.
Finally,
I go to church because I want to change the world (thanks Gerald!).
Peace always . . .